In this article
Schlittler shuts down Boston again in October
Schlittler allowed only two singles and one walk while striking out 10, and Boston did not get a runner to second base against him. Yankees manager Aaron Boone removed him with one out in the seventh after Wilyer Abreu singled, and the Yankee Stadium crowd of 48,437 sent him off with a standing ovation and chants rarely aimed at a pitcher.
The outing continued an unusually one-sided run for Schlittler against the team he grew up around in Massachusetts. Including the playoffs, he is 4-1 with a 0.47 ERA and 49 strikeouts in six career starts against the Red Sox. A year earlier, he struck out 12 over eight scoreless innings in a 4-0 win that ended Boston’s season in a decisive Wild Card Game 3.
Schlittler threw 117 pitches, the most by a Yankees postseason starter since CC Sabathia in the 2012 Division Series. He generated a career-high 24 swings and misses and leaned more heavily than usual on his curveball, using it far more often than during the regular season and producing a 57% whiff rate with the pitch.
Ben Rice turns a tight game into a Yankees runaway
New York led only 1-0 until the fifth inning, after Austin Wells had driven in the first run with a second-inning single. Rice then hit a 423-foot solo homer into Monument Park off left-handed reliever Erik Miller, who had just replaced Boston rookie starter Payton Tolle after 83 pitches.
Rice kept adding damage late. He singled home a run with the bases loaded in the seventh, then hit a grand slam to right-center off Brayan Bello in the eighth as part of a five-run inning. He finished 4-for-5 with two home runs, a double, six RBIs and more hits by himself than Boston’s entire lineup, which had three.
The night put Rice in Yankees postseason history. His six RBIs tied the franchise single-game playoff record, and he became the first Yankee and the sixth player in major league history with at least four hits and six RBIs in a postseason game. The grand slam was the 16th in Yankees postseason history.
Two New England products beat Boston from the Bronx
The matchup carried an added local twist because both of New York’s biggest Game 1 contributors came from Red Sox territory. Schlittler is a Massachusetts native who attended Northeastern, while Rice grew up about a 45-minute drive from Fenway Park and went to Dartmouth. The Yankees drafted Schlittler in the seventh round and Rice in the 12th round in consecutive years.
Rice was not a Red Sox fan as a child; he said wearing a Yankees jersey to first-grade picture day likely drew unusual looks. Boone called the joint performance by Schlittler and Rice “pretty remarkable,” noting that their Boston-area backgrounds have become part of the rivalry’s recent storyline.
Their performances also reflected broader 2026 breakthroughs. Schlittler entered the postseason as the clear frontrunner for the American League Cy Young Award after leading the league with a 1.95 ERA, while Rice led New York with 41 home runs, 97 RBIs and an .897 OPS in his third major league season.
Boston faces elimination in Game 2
The Yankees opened the series without Aaron Judge, who was sidelined by a calf injury, yet still produced 12 hits and their largest shutout postseason win since the 1960 World Series. George Lombard Jr., a 21-year-old rookie, went 3-for-4 in his postseason debut, and Wells drove in two runs from the No. 9 spot.
Game 2 is scheduled for Wednesday night at Yankee Stadium, with Boston right-hander Sonny Gray set to face Yankees left-hander Max Fried. The series is airing on NBC and streaming on Peacock; the Wild Card round is best of three, so a New York victory in Game 2 would send the Yankees to a Division Series against the AL East champion Tampa Bay Rays.
History also gives Game 1 added weight, though it does not decide the series by itself. Since MLB introduced the best-of-three Wild Card Series format in 2022, Game 1 winners had advanced in 15 of 16 series entering this postseason. The only exception was Boston last year, before Schlittler’s decisive Game 3 performance swung the rivalry series to New York.