In this article
Late rulings changed the debate format
According to Globo’s statement, the first court order came from the Superior Electoral Court, or TSE, and was signed by Minister Stella Aranha. It granted a request from Lula’s campaign coalition and invalidated the part of the debate rules that dealt with absent candidates. Lula, the PT candidate and sitting president, had informed organizers on Wednesday, September 30, that he would not attend the event.
The rules agreed in advance, Globo said, required that an absent candidate’s lectern remain on stage, empty and identified with a nameplate. They also allowed participating candidates, during one free-theme round, to use 30 seconds to formulate a question they would have directed to the absent candidate. The TSE decision barred Globo from showing Lula’s named empty lectern and from allowing those questions.
The second ruling cited by Globo came from Supreme Federal Court Minister Gilmar Mendes and ordered the inclusion of Renan Santos, the presidential candidate of Missão. That decision followed earlier denials of similar requests: one from TSE president Kassio Nunes Marques on Wednesday and another from Supreme Court Minister Cármen Lúcia hours before Mendes’s decision.
Who Globo had invited and why Renan Santos became a dispute
Globo said the legal rule for mandatory invitations to radio and television debates is based on congressional representation: parties with at least five members in the National Congress must have their presidential candidates invited. Applying that standard, the broadcaster had invited Augusto Cury of Avante, Flavio Bolsonaro of PL, Ronaldo Caiado of PSD and Lula of PT.
Before the cancellation, the field had already shifted. Globo said a Tuesday decision by TSE president Kassio Nunes Marques changed the court’s own understanding of how to count congressional members for debate purposes and gave Romeu Zema of Novo the right to participate. Mendes’s later order added Renan Santos even though, according to Globo’s statement, Missão had only one lawmaker in Congress.
Sporting News also reported that Flávio Bolsonaro, the PL candidate, withdrew from the encounter in the hours before it was to air. The supplied evidence does not give his reason for dropping out, so the confirmed sequence is limited to Lula’s prior absence, the court orders affecting the rules and participation list, and Globo’s final decision to cancel.
Globo cited legal uncertainty and interference
In its cancellation statement, Globo argued that the successive rulings issued shortly before airtime created legal uncertainty and amounted to improper interference with the freedom of media outlets to organize election debates. The broadcaster said its purpose in hosting such programs was to promote discussion of ideas for Brazil and give voters a chance to compare political projects.
Three press organizations — the Brazilian Association of Radio and Television Broadcasters, the National Association of Magazine Editors and the National Newspaper Association — issued a joint note supporting Globo. They described the judicial intervention as a serious affront to press freedom and said the court actions overrode rules that had been agreed months earlier between the broadcaster and the parties.
The associations also argued that the episode affected voters’ access to candidates’ proposals. Their statement framed the cancellation not merely as a private dispute over a television format, but as a public electoral issue because the debate had been intended as the final presidential debate before the first round, according to the reporting supplied.
What aired instead and what viewers were told
Globo informed viewers of the cancellation around 8:40 p.m., roughly 50 minutes before the planned 9:30 p.m. start. In place of the debate, the broadcaster said it would air a new episode of the telenovela “Quem Ama Cuida.” The immediate practical result was that the presidential confrontation scheduled for that night did not take place.
Some viewers also searched for whether a football match would replace the canceled debate, but Sporting News reported that no game was scheduled on Globo that Thursday night. The Campeonato Brasileiro was paused because of the FIFA international window, and the next Globo football broadcast listed in the evidence was Brazil’s friendly against India on Saturday at 11 a.m. Brasília time.